"Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and Me" by Gary Presley
by Llalan • 08.09.2011Today marks the 66th anniversary of the bombing of Nagasaki in World War II. Gary Presley, author of The Wind (Issue 26), writes of his memories and impressions of the war as an “army brat” whose father served in the war.
Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and Me
What stands in my memory is a tower. The tower marked the point over which The Bomb exploded. If you are of a generation touched by World War II, you invariably use those words whether you speak of Hiroshima or Nagasaki: The Bomb.
I can tell you I was five or six or seven years old. I don’t remember exactly, but we visited Nagasaki and Hiroshima sometime in the late 1940s when the cities were still mostly rubble. I know it was before 1950, because in 1950 our family lived in an rickety apartment converted from an army hospital ward at Fort Jackson, South Carolina. I know that because my brother was born in 1950.
Here is a thing that confuses me further, these sixty years on, years overlaid by television and film documentaries, by books and magazines: I do not know whether the tower was in Hiroshima or Nagasaki. We visited both, my family did, and there are pictures stored away in my father’s 35mm slide collection of Nagasaki, Hiroshima, and of the idyllic untouched Japan of rice paddies, shrines, and Mount Fuji. My father was stationed in Japan those years, assigned as a general’s aide-de-camp, and my mother and I had sailed on an old troop ship to join him there. Because the general lived alone during that period, and perhaps because our family reminded him of better days, we three often traveled with him on casual trips.
I remember the atomic ruins as well, rolling away from our little group in waves of rubble perhaps three feet tall, streets and alleys clear, debris piled along side. The scraps of memory from long ago conjure up shards of concrete and metal, and a few twisted and broken trees dotting an otherwise flat, featureless landscape. I remember a wrecked building, which I later learned was the remnants of the Prefectural Industrial Promotion Hall, and the wreck’s domed roof, or at least what was left of it. And other buildings – a hospital? – with shadows lingering on the walls, shadows created by the fission flash of Little Boy or Fat Man.
How does a child contemplate death? No one close in my life then had died, no grandparent, no aunt, nor uncle or cousin killed in the war. How can a child comprehend thousands dead? I was told The Bomb had been dropped to end the war, and I believed. The Bomb was real then, even if I could not walk down the ruined street and understand all that had lived and thrived there before, all that had been good, and evil.
An army lives to impose the will of a state, by force, That I know now. Then I was an army brat, and with my toy soldiers and model airplanes and my little collection of colorful infantry and armored division insignia my father helped me collect. I fantasized I was part of the army. My father had taken refuge in the army during the Depression, had done well, attended OCS, and decided to remain a soldier after the war.
The army was my home, familiar in its sameness even in the exotic places it had taken me. Our family marched to its rhythms, and my father dressed each morning in his uniform and became a soldier, and I saw the uniform and was proud, but, at heart, at five or six years old, I was oblivious to its grand design and the means by which it sought to achieve it.
It is sixty years now, and whatever I see through the mist of memory, I cannot remember the voice of anyone in the general’s party gloating over the destruction we found at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Even later, as my father was transferred from one fort to another, I remember talk of The Bomb only as salvation.
That, and perhaps also that a hard-edged comprehension that the covenant with our own dead had been fulfilled.
The machinations of history were beyond me then, a little boy clinging to his mother’s hand. It was years before I could recognize the message of victory and its price. I know now that many of the men I saw every day, the soldiers wearing the Combat Infantryman badge, the Purple Heart, and decorations for valor, had faced down the Panzers on the frozen fields of the Bulge or fought, riddled with dengue, beriberi, and malaria, to beat and burn the Emperor’s warriors off dozens of Pacific jungle islands.
During the war, my father served in the Philippines, on Okinawa, and then his division went to Seoul to take the surrender of Imperial Army units there. My father’s division would have been one among many sent to invade the main Japanese islands had The Bomb not be dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
In most human beings there is a place in the heart, I think, where we celebrate the triumph of blood.
It is the same hot, hard unreasoning same place where lived the primitive man who struck out with club or rock or teeth to save what is his. And in that dark recess of my soul, I believe the dead of Hiroshima and Nagasaki are no different from the dead in the firestorms of Dresden, Hamburg, or Tokyo. Or the dead in Nanking. Or Manila.
I remain an army brat, even now all these years later. I will always and forever dismiss the caveats and doubts and moralizing from those who had no power then, in that desperate hour, to choose who would live and who would die. No one who quibbles today, who speaks of moral choices, was alive then to take up a rifle and lead a company of infantry ashore on Kyushu.
The Bomb dropped. My father survived. My brother lives.

I appreciated the honest, intelligent reasoning that went into the writing of this story about the bomb. It made me sit back and consider again how many lives were saved by its use, something I always knew but needed a reminder of in our current ‘how could we?’ mindset.
Good piece, Gary. Honest.
My father served in the Pacific Theater, Okinawa. And, of course, I too have heard/read the arguments and debates on the moral questions involved, doubts that haunt us still. But in the end, my father came home from that war as did my father-in-law. Everything I know and love hinges on that fact–they came home. Otherwise, my husband and I would be members of the unborn, unrealized club. As would our children.
So I, too, will leave the moralizing to others because I suspect I owe my life to that final decision as hard and terrible as it may have been.
It is said that the war came to an end and was won by the Allies because of the Bomb. But, one must remember; wars are not won but only lost. It is not who wins a war, but rather who loses the least.
An excellent memoir, Gary. I’m so glad you wrote this down. We still live in the shadow of WWII, although not that many realize it, and so much of the daily, lived history of that era is being / has been lost. I don’t think I’ve read anything quite like this, and I’ve read a fair amount on the decision (and consequences) of dropping The Bomb. Was it the right decision? The wrong decision? Was it for revenge, to end the war (was an invasion necessary or could a siege have broken the Japanese?), to warn off the Soviets from moving into Korea and Japan…all those things, and more, it was the right decision and the wrong decision. Your excellent essay shows that moral complexity.
Some who have commented on this essay have noted it is straight-forward and, for lack of a better word, “accepting.”
The essay is partly inspired by my confusion over the idea that the dead from the atomic weapons are different from the dead from the deliberate firestorms set by the Allies in the latter part of WW II.
Millions died to defeat the Nazis and Imperial Japan. That is the single simple truth, and it matters not to the dead whether it was by being beaten to death, beheaded with a samuri sword, shot to fall in a trench in eastern Europe, gassed in a concentration camp, or by bombing, atomic or otherwise.
We are a brutal species, we humans.
Hallo there, Gary,
I had never thought of myself as a military brat … but I suppose I would be. My great-grandfather (and his brother), my grandfather (and his brother), and my father (and his two brothers) were all in the British military, all but one in the Royal Navy. My grandfather was a RN signalman at Dunnet Head (north Scotland) during WW2, two of his sons were on ships overseas, one on the tugs operating in the Dockyard at Chatham. I even have a cousin in the Royal Navy right now, an officer.
Growing up, I do not ever recall my military relatives, or their female counterparts, boasting of what they did to win the war. I think there may have been some shared sorrow.
As a child, I saw a film on Hiroshima at school. Everything looked so silent, so still. When I was a teenager I bought Jefferson Airplane’s “Crown of Creation” album with the atomic bomb cloud on the cover. Somehow, I associate Hiroshima with “Greasy Heart”. I read “Slaughterhouse 5″, of course. And Janis Ian sang a song “Hiroshima”. As they did.
There’s a statue of “Bomber” Harris near the Houses of Parliament in London. Sir Arthur was responsible for our bombing arrangements during WW2. Think Dresden.
I’ve not felt inclined to walk over to see Harris’s statue. I am not sure if a monument to one man, concerning the deaths of so many, is appropriate. He was not a politician, but a kind of technician.
I have a great-uncle killed in the last days of the First World War in the Pas de Calais. Sometimes I feel awfully sad thinking of him dying away from his family. His death certificate does not say how exactly he died. And, more terrifying to me, I wonder if he killed anyone, any Germans, before he fell.
I stood in the same spot in Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1962. At that time there was a tree planted under the spot where the Bomb exploded in one of the Cities. I also visited a Shrine and saw Body parts and Pics. Needless to say it was an experience that I live with to this day. at that time there was some Rebuilding, but the Homes were poorly constructed and there was still a lot of unemployment and poverty.
I still believe that dropping the Bombs was the only course of action, after the way the the Japanese Military behaved at Okinawa.